[ login or create an account ]
|
Wellington, Sept 3 NZPA - The presence of an extra police officer at the search of Jan Molenaar's home could have saved the life of Senior Constable Len Snee, coroner David Crerar said today.
Molenaar, 51, shot dead Mr Snee and wounded two other officers, Senior Constables Grant Diver and Bruce Miller, after they attempted to carry out a cannabis search at Molenaar's Napier property on May 7 last year.
Civilian Len Holmwood, who had been visiting Molenaar when the officers went to carry out the search, tried to intervene and was also shot and injured.
Molenaar later shot himself dead, ending a three-day siege.
Mr Crerar released his findings into both deaths today following an inquest from March 30 to April 1.
Among his findings, Mr Crerar found that if another officer had been present at the search then Mr Snee might not have been killed.
"Although I agree that more police at the time of the execution of the search warrant may have had the outcome of more shooting victims, it is clear that the presence of an extra police officer may have avoided the tragic outcome," Mr Crerar said.
"Constable Snee could not adequately control Lenny Holmwood, Delwyn Keefe and Jan Molenaar and it would have been better if a police constable had accompanied Jan Molenaar when he left the room."
While Mr Crerar agreed with police that Molenaar's response to a police search was totally disproportionate to the seriousness of the incident, he said police had insufficient intelligence about Molenaar.
Mr Crerar also questioned the community's inaction in coming forward with information about his state of mind.
"Intelligence relies on public support," Mr Crerar said.
"A number of persons, including some who gave evidence to the inquest hearing, knew that Jan Molenaar would be upset by the entry of police on to his property.
"Each and every person who knew, or considered it possible, that Jan Molenaar would react in a violent manner or in a way the police may have considered to be unpredictable, owes a responsibility to report their concerns to police.
"There is a matter of enduring regret that this did not happen."
Among Mr Crerar's recommendations was a review of the Arms Act, which he said was currently only complied with by honest people.
He also made several recommendations for changes to police search procedures, which police today said had already been addressed.
The report described how Molenaar's partner, Delwyn Keefe, tried to stop Molenaar when she saw that he had a rifle aimed at the three police constables.
"Delwyn Keefe said that she ran towards Jan Molenaar with her arms in the air and told Jan Molenaar to put the gun down," the report said.
"She then turned her back to Jan Molenaar and said to the constables: 'Get out, because you don't know him like I do'."
Keefe provided the court with two notes left for her by Molenaar which read: "I was bad. I paid for my crime. I let everyone down, I know. JM" and "I love you Del, you are so loyal, faithful, good person. I did my best to make you happy, love JaniMo forever".
Keefe told the court she believed the notes were indicative of Molenaar's remorse.
Keefe was last year sentenced to two years and three months' jail after being convicted on cannabis charges.
The coroner found that Mr Snee died as a result of wounds from gunshots fired by Molenaar and that Molenaar died from a self-inflicted bullet wound to the head.
Popular competitions and giveaways from Gimme.co.nz: NZ's People Powered Guide to Free Stuff. Links will open on Gimme.
Health Tips, Recommended Movies, Recommended Books, Recommended Places.
Links will open on recommended.co.nz.
All articles and comments on Voxy.co.nz have been submitted by our community of users. Please notify us through our contact form if you believe an item on this site breaches our community guidelines.
Voxy: Your Voice - Uncensored
Got Something to Say But No One’s Listening?
Message to Spread? – Distribute News
Product to Promote? – Run a Promotion
We Can Help You Spread The Word.
Comments
Well Done Mr Coroner! And an
Well Done Mr Coroner! And an Armed Offenders Officer stationed on every street corner may have allowed an instant response as well...but the reality is that two officers attended a call out, not three or four or however many more. I guess a whole bus load would have helped heaps. Your 20/20 hindsight is brilliant, but there are simply not enough police officers to have then patrol in threes and fours. As an aside , if they were carrying sidearms all the time they may also have helped...but that is supposition too.
Not the first time that I
Not the first time that I have seen Coroner's in this country come out with the most incredibly inane comments with the benefit of hindsight. I actually wonder sometimes why we even have a Coroner's office. A blind person could frequently come out with the same words of wisdom and not cost 10's of thousands of dollars and months of time to come to the same conclusion. Coroner McElrea in Christchurch is amongst the worst.
An extra bit of attention to
An extra bit of attention to drug policy could have saved these Policemen and their dogs...
Of cannabis had been put into the "restricted substances regulations" design to really CONTROL recreational psychoactive soft drugs.... they WOULD ALL BE ALIVE.
(Yes that's the law made by Anderton et al just before Key became right and honourable on a law and order ticket)
New Zealand made the most sensible law change to add an extension to the Misuse of Drugs Act making provision for use of soft drugs, R18, place of sale, advertising, labeling and packaging... the works. It was gazetted in oct 2008 and became law the very day John Key won the election.
So where is the Coroner game enough to say.. put resources into what works and manage the rest, not hand it over to gangsta culture and the corruption of our national drug intelligence bureau who are prepared to lie and overstate their case against cannabis like they are experts. They are not. And they bloody know it.
Its a graft of multimillion dollar proportions. They have a monopoly in the truth and the media.
This was revealed when a researcher with teh Christchurch multidicplinary study showed that 80% of its subject base of 1000 had used cannabis and of those very few caught and prosecuted the law did NOTHING to stop use. So why do we do it again.. is the price paid by honourable men on mission impossible worth it when pot is yet to kill anyone. It is safer than peanut butter. And certainly safer than alcohol.
Where is the Coroner's advice now? Boxed in by the Dogma?