Recommended NZ | Guide to Money | Gimme: Competitions - Giveaways

National Fails To Listen To Mainstream

Contributor:
Fuseworks Media
Fuseworks Media

Students are slamming today's Select Committee recommendation that the Act Party's Education (Freedom of Association) Amendment Bill go forward. The recommendation ignores the 98% of submissions against it and is putting students' services, representation, and the quality of their education at major risk.

"This irresponsible recommendation is very disappointing. The government members of the Committee have failed to listen to students and the public. National has chosen to ignore the overwhelming opposition to the Bill, as well as the many compelling policy and practical arguments to maintain or enhance the current law," says NZUSA Co-President David Do.

The Committee received 4837 submissions on the Bill, with an overwhelming 98% opposed. Submitters against included thousands of students, the Human Rights Commission, Ako Aotearoa (National Centre for Tertiary Teaching Excellence), Rural Women New Zealand, and many universities and polytechnics around the country. Only a mere 89 submissions supported the Bill.*

"The mainstream clearly supports the status quo. The Committee received and heard overwhelming evidence that students are served well by students' associations under the current law," says Do.

"National has previously sought to govern in a practical, pragmatic way, and look at what works best. It is therefore hard to understand why National has now chosen to ignore the evidence and the will of students and the public on this issue. Instead, National is choosing to reward a discredited fringe party by supporting this unwanted, unwarranted, destructive Act Party Bill," says Do.

Strong evidence in both Australia and New Zealand shows that this Bill will destroy student representation and welfare provision, and put student-owned services like Student Job Search at risk. Student life, events like Orientation, clubs, and sports will be at risk, and institutions and Government will face extra new costs.

"Generations of New Zealanders have gone through higher education and benefited from the good work and significant gains students' associations have made for students. Successive generations benefited from the many clubs, activities, services, facilities and representation of their students' associations. The Act Party Bill will kill off these opportunities for future generations of students," says NZUSA co-President Pene Delaney.

"The Act Party Bill is an ideological solution in search of a problem. It is bad policy to impose such upheaval and chaos when there are many bigger issues facing the tertiary sector and New Zealand right now. When the quality of education and the student experience is at stake, this Bill is simply not worth the risk," says Delaney.

"We call on National to see sense and reject the Act Party Bill. Students and the public will continue to campaign and rally for this Bill to be defeated in Parliament," concludes Delaney.

NZUSA is the national representative body for tertiary students and has been advocating on student issues since 1929.

* Note: This is based on an analysis of the substantive submissions supporting the Bill posted on the Parliament website.

Comments

When they say "students"

When they say "students" they mean the ones who actually paid attention to this law. Considering that of these so called "98% of submissions" only a fraction of these were from students who were not from a union/Labour background. In fact most submissions were from ex student union presidents, executive members and others well within the union movement. Ironically, those working within unions today all benefit from voluntary unions within our workplaces AND NZUSA is a voluntary union.

At the Otago Polytechnic today they held a vote to see if students wanted to leave NZUSA. Out of 7100 students there only about 50 voted, but they voted overwhelmingly to leave NZUSA. NZUSA is no longer the voice for students, they are a well funded political campaigning tool for aspiring Labour MPs. Don't believe me, read the submissions.

This bill has done nothing bad. It is simple. When you enrol, you get given a choice - do you join or not join the student union. It isn't the end of the world, if your union has been doing a good job then what is there to fear?

I will tell you what they have to fear - they know that the reason why they still exist is because of apathy and ignorance. If every student knew they were funding political campaigns and millions of dollars of projects, they would be more vocal at election times. But most campuses struggle to get a 10% turnout. They fear the gravytrain is going to be over for them and that is why NZUSA is so upset today.

If it was me I'd be upset too.

Of course student's

Of course student's associations are upset, now they are accountable and actually have to provide benefit to their students, there was never any motivation to do that in the past.

EXACTLY! No other

EXACTLY! No other organisation would survive if they didn't have to listen to their members. This will teach some of them how to "listen".. although in all honesty all we will see is some stroppy NZUSA (Labour) staffers on TV telling everybody the world is about to end.

Surely if there is 98%

Surely if there is 98% submissions opposing, then there would be 98% voluntary members! Elementary!

- legend! I will have to

- legend! I will have to borrow this quote!

It is too easy to take a

It is too easy to take a swipe at Student unions they are an easy target. However it is the same old story You don't know what you have got till it's gone.
The same idealogues thought that unions were too powerful and effectively destroyed worker representation with the ECA. The result: NZers now earn very low wages and will do so forever more.

How are they an "easy

How are they an "easy target" Xrunner? They have budgets of well over a million dollars and have activists from the far left who run their "campaigns" and smear attacks against those who disagree with them. Not to mention they have backing from our trade unions, who are NOT destroyed. The CTU and EPMU are still strong and powerful - look at how many of them are in the Labour Party.

Funny that you forget one fundamental point. When given a choice, workers chose NOT to join a trade union. Why is that? are you advocating that all workers and students be forced against their will to join a union for their own good?

Student Unions are an easy

Student Unions are an easy political target.

What I know exactly is this that most people would benefit from collective bargaining but are unable to do so when confronted with individual contracts. That is the norm now for most. I think my own experience is typical. I was bullied to accept a nil pay increase this year but stood my ground and finally got 2%, this knowing that the company had made mega dollars the past year.
When union membership was compulsory pay rises were regular and even handed for all. I know that where I work most accepted nil this year.
NZers are hard working people when given incentive enough, the threat of having no job is no incentive.
The strong union you mention the EPMU is fortunate and long may it live.
I think you have a bit of the conspiracy theory going on, and see reds under every bed. You need to be careful when throwing the baby out with the bath water as the Act student bill will do. The consequences years ahead might well be unpalatable. National have found that out with the ECA, anybody with any ability went to Australia and the tax take has become low with crap wages. Quote Bill English "We set out to create a low wage low cost society" Well they got the first part right.

Nope, they are not an easy

Nope, they are not an easy political target. Your comment seems quite in line with what is coming out of the mouths of our trade union leaders - who incidentally support only a small minority of workers. You are also advocating that all workers should join a trade union too I bet.

Your comment has nothing to do with students - it has everything to do with the trade union movement. This is the same mentality as our student unions - no wonder apathy is so high, just like it was when all workers were forced to be in a trade union.

The EPMU is strong AND has voluntary membership. Long may voluntary membership live.

Your comment speaks volumes about the mentality of student unions. Completely out of touch and not supported by the majority of students who (believe it or not) go to University to get a degree - not to fund workers political movements.

Whatever but be prepared to

Whatever but be prepared to live in a society with very low wages and take the consequences. Make sure you keep up your insurances. The low paid will be around to suss out what they need and will take it

And that has what exactly to

And that has what exactly to do with a student association? (answer - none) Keep your revolution inside your head Chris, it isn't going to happen even if you shut your eyes really tightly and beg for it :)

Competitions and Giveaways from Gimme.co.nz

Popular competitions and giveaways from Gimme.co.nz: NZ's People Powered Guide to Free Stuff.  Links will open on Gimme.

Featured Recommendations from recommended.co.nz

All articles and comments on Voxy.co.nz have been submitted by our community of users. Please notify us through our contact form if you believe an item on this site breaches our community guidelines.