[ login or create an account ]
|
Wellington, Jan 21 NZPA - The New Zealand Herald says it published a photo of two New Zealand SAS soldiers in Afghanistan for its news value and doesn't believe the men were put at risk by its decision.
One of the men pictured in the photo taken in the capital Kabul has been identified as Corporal Willie Apiata, the first soldier to win the Victoria Cross since World War 2.
The New Zealand soldiers were in the city helping restore order after Taliban gunmen and suicide bombers attacked this week.
The photo was taken by photographer Philip Poupin and published in The New Zealand Herald today.
The paper's assistant editor John Roughan said staff did not know Cpl Apiata was in the photo when they decide to print it on the basis of its "strong news value".
"It was New Zealand's first glimpse of our forces in Kabul," he told Radio New Zealand.
"We didn't even know they were there until a few days beforehand, when the New York Times revealed it to us...this was the first chance we had to actually look at them, to see them in action."
Mr Roughan did not believe publication put the soldiers at risk.
"That's something that we always consider, but in this case the soldiers were out in a public place, in a public street, in a major city, visible to anybody, wearing uniform, carrying their guns...there seemed no reason for the Herald or anybody else to hide their identities."
The paper would not have printed Cpl Apiata's name, he said.
"We wouldn't have identified him in that sense, but when he's on patrol, in Kabul, in public, we don't think that he's preserved from being photographed."
The paper would do the same thing again, "... if we had pictures of news value and we were confident that they wouldn't put anybody at risk."
New Zealand Defence Force spokesman, Commander Shaun Fogarty, refused to say if publication of the photograph was likely to make Cpl Apiata a greater target among Taliban.
"Those are operational issues and we don't comment on the operational issues of the SAS and that won't change."
Afghanistan was an "extreme risk environment", he said.
"It is high-risk for anyone there, particularly serving with the special forces.
"Any photo of this nature is of concern to the New Zealand Defence Force whether it be Cpl Apiata of anyone else serving there. We are very disappointed."
Cpl Apiata's future in Afghanistan was an operational issue, which would not be discussed, Cdr Fogarty said.
The publication of the photograph broke a long-standing convention -- "a robust gentlemen's arrangement with all New Zealand media agencies that photos like this would not be published, which compromise the safety of our people serving the country overseas."
The publication would be discussed with the Herald newspaper.
Prime Minister John Key said he was "very disappointed" with the Herald, which should have blacked out the men's faces.
A high level of secrecy was needed for the SAS, he said.
"The Taliban and Al Qaeda were always aware they were there so there was no secret that the New Zealand SAS were in Kabul.
"But we don't want them to know the names and individual identities of members of the SAS because of the nature of some of their operations, and they would be at a greater risk if they can be identified."
The publication of the photograph put Cpl Apiata's life and the lives of other SAS soldiers at risk, Mr Key said.
He thought it was unlikely Cpl Apiata would return to New Zealand before the end of his rotation.
"At the end of the day, people knew he was in the SAS and there was always the chance people might take the view that he might be back there."
Cpl Apiata won the Victoria Cross in 2004 after he hoisted a wounded comrade onto his back and carried him to safety after his SAS unit was ambushed at night on a hillside outside a village in Afghanistan.
Medics said the wounded soldier needed urgent medical treatment and would almost certainly have died if Cpl Apiata had not carried him 70 metres through heavy fire to safety.
He rearmed himself and rejoined the firefight.
Popular competitions and giveaways from Gimme.co.nz: NZ's People Powered Guide to Free Stuff. Links will open on Gimme.
Health Tips, Recommended Movies, Recommended Books, Recommended Places.
Links will open on recommended.co.nz.
All articles and comments on Voxy.co.nz have been submitted by our community of users. Please notify us through our contact form if you believe an item on this site breaches our community guidelines.
Voxy: Your Voice - Uncensored
Got Something to Say But No One’s Listening?
Message to Spread? – Distribute News
Product to Promote? – Run a Promotion
We Can Help You Spread The Word.
Comments
I think the publishing of
I think the publishing of the faces of SAS soldiers is an indication that the NZ Herald has no respect for the unwritten law that the identity of our boys serving in this unit is never revealed. This includes showing their faces, this is a small country & of course people will recognise them. Shame on you NZ Herald.
Agree - a disgrace.
Agree - a disgrace. Worthiness is a judgement call based on balancing the need to publish information for the public good with that of the individuals or groups reported on. For the herald and "stuff" for that matter to 1, deem it worthy and 2 say they would do it again if ..."confident that they wouldn't put anybody at risk." shows the poor state of their judgement since they could not posibility be confident,to any degree, of the safety of any member of the SAS. The chain of command within the unit assess that. A futher example of poor press seeking to understand the popular opinion,feeding it and getting it wrong was the rubbish from Romanos (12/01/10) on Chris Cains registered 165 comments, the majority - 95% - agreed with Cains. He's not now or ever was or sort to be a hero.
Does any person/or body check the quality of the news - other than liable?