[ login or create an account ]
|

A Facebook group caught my attention, "We don't want Cow Cubicles in New Zealand." My ears pricked up.
With no previous knowledge of the issue, my first impression brought to mind the image of battery hens, chooks raised in cages, and how farmers earn more for the eggs they sell if they are certified as "Free-Range." I imagined a future in which "Factory Farming" became the norm and non-conventional farmers charged more for their Free-Range dairy products. An inspector from the SPCA would have to visit the farm, inspecting the paddock to ensure the cow was indeed ranging freely, as is the case with chooks.
No, I thought. It sounds too unnatural. Too cruel to farm like that. So in an attempt to disprove my disillusions about the practice, I had to read more. This is what I found out.
"Three companies have applied for resource consent to house 18,000 cows in European-style 'cubicles' for eight months of the year." A great number of Kiwi's are opposed to this proposal and I decided I was one of them.
Numerous reasons were given as to why the practice is opposed - the focus being based on environmental reasons in order to relevantly address the application in regards to resource management requirements. Among some of the given reasons were: it's bad for the cows, bad for the environment, creates a disproportionate amount of waste, consumes a disproportionate amount of water, is bad for public health (e.g. increases the risk of spreading E.Coli bacteria), is bad for the dairy industry and bad for tourism. More emotive reasons for opposing the practise included, "It's not Kiwi... Not in New Zealand!" And honestly, even if I did not have access to the research which highlights the negative environmental and health impacts, I think I would still be opposed to it on those simple emotive grounds - it's not Kiwi. Not in New Zealand. I grew up on a farm, and like my fellow hillbilly friends in the wops, we learned to treat animals and the land with love and respect. My emotional response is, how could animals be treated that way??
Unfortunately, by the time I accessed the homepage providing this information, I discovered that I had already missed one of the deadlines in order to make submissions against one of the Resource Management Applications. However, there is still time to make submissions before the 18th of December if you are interested in sharing your views. Click here and here to open pages where you can make submissions either for or against the applications for the companies Five River Limited and Southdown Holdings Limited. For more information about making a submission and submission guidelines, www.greens.org.nz has provided a Guide.
Ironically, the deadline for submissions shares the same date as the closing of the 2009 United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen. World Leaders seem to be (trying) to head towards greener pastures... carbon emission reductions, renewable and cleaner sources of energy, less waste... In that regard, is "Factory Farming" innovative or counter-productive? Behind the sense of pride we feel to be Kiwis, I think we all know that we're not as clean and green as we are percieved to be overseas... Perhaps like never before in history, people are tuning in to critically eye what individuals and nations are doing in regard to peace, nature and human resources. Can New Zealanders afford to take our positive "clean, green" image for granted? Hopefully by the close of December 18th, not only world leaders will have made progress for the future, but we too, as individuals and communities will have taken action to support a better tomorrow for places a little closer to home.
To join the Facebook group (if you're into that sort of thing) click here. However, this is an issue that should not be solely confined within the gossipy, narcissistic depths of Facebook. If you want to maintain free-range dairy products for New Zealand and preserve the lifestyle of cattle in the outdoors, where they can walk about, graze and breath fresh air, then make a submission to Resource Management and express your view before Friday the 18th.
Popular competitions and giveaways from Gimme.co.nz: NZ's People Powered Guide to Free Stuff. Links will open on Gimme.
Health Tips, Recommended Movies, Recommended Books, Recommended Places.
Links will open on recommended.co.nz.
All articles and comments on Voxy.co.nz have been submitted by our community of users. Please notify us through our contact form if you believe an item on this site breaches our community guidelines.
Voxy: Your Voice - Uncensored
Got Something to Say But No One’s Listening?
Message to Spread? – Distribute News
Product to Promote? – Run a Promotion
We Can Help You Spread The Word.
Comments
Excellent piece Dallas. Very
Excellent piece Dallas. Very good summary.
As far as I can tell, you
As far as I can tell, you haven't missed the submission deadline for Williamson Holdings as it looks like it has been extended till 15 January 2010.
Brilliant, thanks for the
Brilliant, thanks for the info!
This is very True.I agree
This is very True.I agree completely.
I fully agree (but you knew
I fully agree (but you knew that already). There was an article on the news the other night that featured a cubicle-farm and showed how happy his cows are. Made the SAFE representative look like a retard. Didn't talk about the environmental issues at all though, which is what the resource proposal are concerned with. Gotta love emotive NZ news
Thanks Kate. Submissions in
Thanks Kate. Submissions in regard to the Resource Consent Applications should be kept reasonably emotion-free and focus instead on environmental and public health research if we want to argue realistic reasons why this is a bad idea.
I think that we would do
I think that we would do well to have a central place to collect relevant information specific to these consents. Im thinking "dump a whole lot of poo in a paddock and hope it doesnt leech", and treating a large area like a big soak pit for pooze, and what the results of that might be over the 35 year trial period, and opposing it somewhat from that angle.
The other stuff counts too but thats bedtime reading for David Carter MP.
He's the (animal welfare) man. He has the power to put the Animal Welfare Act 1999 Back on the table for discussion and revision. That discussion will be long and unpleasant. I wonder how long he avoids it for.
Merry Christmas everyone and this Christmas, spare a thought for the turkeys and the pigs?
The cow's go mooooo, they
The cow's go mooooo, they are my favourite yeeeeh haaah!
Stop posting comments and
Stop posting comments and using my name Chris.
I don't want to be too
I don't want to be too cynical, but it's great to read that even the young and trendy (am I prejudiced or what?) have cottoned on to food-related animal welfare problems. Yay for Dallas!
Please don't stop here everybody - there's heaps to do because there are so many things wrong with the world we live in. Drinking organic milk and eating free-range eggs still have ethical questions attached (even on organic dairy farms the male calves are sent to the works and male chicks are put into the meat grinder a short time after they're born).
If you want to know how cattle feedlots work, read the wonderful "My Year of Meat" by Ruth L Ozeki (http://www.recommended.co.nz/books/dodgy-meat-and-other-issues/27/128)
Thanks for the comment
Thanks for the comment Sabine! And for calling me trendy! (Which is a bit of a stretch haha).
NO NO NO NO NO NO LO DEJEN
NO NO NO NO NO NO LO DEJEN PASAR!!!!!!!!!!
Exactamente HP!!
Exactamente HP!!